Let's Talk Cake

Carrie was amazing to work with right from the start! She went above and beyond for our tasting, giving us so many options to choose from (all of which were delicious, it was hard to choose!), and carried that over to our wedding day. Our 3 tier naked cake was simply stunning and guests could not stop talking about how good it was. Would absolutely recommend Custom Confections!

-Jennifer  10/4/25

We loved working with Carrie through the entire wedding planning experience. We had an awesome tasting which helped us decide what flavors we wanted for wedding day. The cake was STUNNING and we took some home to freeze for our anniversary. We would recommend Carrie a million times over!

-Mary 9/6/25

Highly recommend! Carrie is amazing! Very attentive, have delicious taste testing to decide which flavor. And my wedding cake Carrie made was so beautiful. She did an amazing job all around. Thank you so much for making this such a great experience and an amazing wedding cake!!! And for your flexibility in helping me with through the process

-Kristi 6/26/25

Carrie Castano baked the most delicious cake we've ever had for our wedding 5/31/25! It was light, flavorful, and perfectly balanced—not overly sweet. The final design was absolutely gorgeous too. I'll update this review with photos once I have them!
 

Carrie was also a dream to work with—friendly, responsive, and quick to communicate. On top of that, her pricing was more than reasonable. Highly recommend!

-Alicia 5/31/25

Carrie was absolutely amazing to work with! She was professional, easy to communicate with, and incredibly flexible. She helped me come with the initial design that so perfect described the Groom. I had a last-minute request to add my dog to the design of the cake, and she not only accommodated it but did so beautifully. The attention to detail was incredible, and the cake was as delicious as it was stunning. I couldn't have asked for a better experience. Highly recommend her for any special occasion!

-Kimmi 10/26/24

I found Carrie when searching up local cake bakers/bake shops in the Hilton Head area for my 20 year wedding vow renewal celebration we had in October. Carrie was SO wonderful and easy to work with, helping us to select the perfect cake. She was so accommodating with every request and even delivered our cake to the venue. The cake was ABSOLUTELY beautiful and delicious! I highly recommend Carrie and Custom Confections!!

-Karissa 10/20/24

Working with Carrie at Custom Confections was surely one of the sweetest things about our wedding! We went all out on desserts and every single item was a delicacy. Our spread consisted of cupcakes, cookies, oreo balls, brownies and even a custom cake for my husband at the rehearsal dinner! My husband and I are still talking about her snickerdoodle cookies and the guests loved the customized cookies we created for wedding favors. Carrie is a dream to work with and she has mastered the art of baking!

Emily 10/23/22

 Planning our wedding from out of town, we booked Custom Confections for our wedding cake based only on online reviews. When we visited Hilton Head a few months before our wedding for a cake tasting we were absolutely blown away!! It is hands down the best cake I've ever had. Carrie did a beautiful wedding cake for us and helped me surprise my husband with an R2D2 cake that turned out absolutely amazing! We are SO happy we found Custom Confections for our wedding and would use them over and over again if we could! 

Samantha 5/5/22

 Highly recommend Custom Confections. My husband and I got married in May and hired Customer Confections for our wedding. We met with Carrie back in January to taste test and go over the cake design. She was amazing from start to finish! Carrie listened to our ideas and was very accommodating. She designed a beautiful and delicious two-tier square cake with a purple ombre icing design for us. It was the perfect size for our small intimate wedding. We also ordered a few dozen mini cupcakes for additional flavor options. It was all so perfect! Our guests raved about Carrie’s work. We are so glad we found Custom Confections and seriously recommend for others to hire for their big day. 

Shelby 5/15/22

 Carrie’s mini cupcakes were a hit with everyone! My only regret was not ordering more!! My guests raved about her cake for weeks :) Her cake holds the perfect amount of sweetness and they don’t leave a sugar aftertaste or film that some cakes do! She was such a pleasure to work with and her cake was so good that we couldn’t decide on just one. I recommend doing mini cupcakes of varying flavors because it was THE BOMB! 

Amanda 5/28/22

 Carrie at Custom Confections did a marvelous job on our wedding cake and groom's cake. We asked for a 3-tiered watercolor design that turned out even more beautiful than we could've imagined. She also made a surprise groom's cake that was an Ibanez electric guitar. A few people thought it was an actual guitar! The detail was incredible!! I loved these cakes so much and just stare at photos of them because they were so pretty. Also, they were delicious! We had four different flavors with scrumptious fillings. I couldn't have asked for a better experience. Plus, we got lots of compliments on how good they looked and tasted! Carrie is also a true professional. She's super responsive, kind, and thoughtful with her craft. We loved working with her and would ask her to do another cake in a heartbeat. She also let us use her gorgeous cake stand to add even more beauty to the presentation. Thank you so much, Carrie!! You made our day truly special--and sweet!

Katherine 11/20/21

 We highly recommend Carrie and Custom Confections for your wedding confections! Carrie worked with our vision and delivered a spectacular cake and presentation that our party completely enjoyed. We really enjoyed the tasting party and had a hard time narrowing our choices of flavors and cake types since they were all excellent. Thank you Carrie for making a great party even better! 

Karen 9/24/21